CHESTERTON HOUSE:
A CENTER FOR CHRISTIAN STUDIES
"daring to discuss the important and the amusing"
NEWSLETTER #19
SPRING 2005
This month's reflections are from InterVarsity chaplain and Chesterton House board
member Christian Anible:
Five years ago, as we were saying
good-bye to the twentieth century and still laughing over the Y2K
scare, I was still fiercely declaring my intention never to own a cell
phone. I refused to accept an electronic tether or be another of the
dupes whose phone rang in the middle of an important meeting. I
gleefully despised Robin Williams' grown-up Pan in Hook,
allowing his cell phone to interrupt precious moments with his
children, and cheered loudly when he threw the damnable item out the
window to ring, forsaken, on the lawn.
Ken Myers, host of
Mars Hill Audio,
published an
editorial that April in which he proposed, "Certainly there are
times when cell phones should be turned off or left at home. Some
restaurants now require guests to disable their cell phones while
dining. This shows respect for the ambience of their dining rooms and
honors the desire of other diners not to be forced into the role of
eavesdropper." He went on to urge "that Christian people in
particular give attention to cell phone etiquette. A thoughtful set of
manners regarding cell phones could be a small but significant way of
reducing the sum total of dehumanizing behavior in American
culture."[1]
Lest we imagine that only
Christians have such stuffy notions, The Cornell Daily Sun ran
an editorial in which Linda Goodman bemoaned "an epidemic of cell
phone usage that seems to have run rampant through the Hill." She
concluded, "As I observe interrupted meals, and the lack of peaceful
walks across campus I am saddened. I've even heard phone chatter
coming from stalls in the ladies room causing me to wonder if we are
nearing a time when privacy at any level is an impossible goal.
Perhaps we will soon forget how to enjoy quiet, and what that even
means."[2]
My own resolve finally flagged
when one of my children was ill and I wanted to be accessible on short
notice. I found the least expensive plan available and gave my phone
number to no one but immediate family. It was an "emergency
phone"-nothing more.
But it wasn't long before I
became enamored with the ease of placing calls in tight spots. Then I
started giving the number to other people in those "one-time"
situations where it would be nice to be accessible. I expect you
can guess the rest of the story. Now my cell phone is my primary
business line, my wife and son have their own units, and I never leave
home without the little monster strapped to my belt. Yes, my friends,
I've sold out.
The whole business still troubles
me. In exchange for all that convenience, I have spent many hours on
hold waiting for customer service in vain attempts to rectify billing
and service problems, and have had plenty of unwelcome
interruptions-not to mention dozens of unintelligible connections and
dropped calls. And the potential for evil only expands as we get
"better" at using the technology.
Last year Cornell Professor Jeff
Hancock asked students to record how many lies they told in a week and
the communication medium they used when they lied. The results?
Subjects told lies in 14 percent of e-mails, 21 percent of instant
messages, 27 percent of face-to-face contact and a whopping 37 percent
of phone calls. According to Hancock, the reason students told so many
lies by phone is because of the physical distance created by the
phone. Simply put, it's harder to lie to someone's
face."[3]
As a matter of fact, you can even
join an "alibi club" in which members lie for one another. Need a
way to get out of an unpleasant date? Get someone to call you with an
"emergency." Want to make the old "had-to-stay-late-at-work"
excuse sound more convincing? Have someone else call your wife with
the bad news.[4]
I could go on about cell phones,
or I could turn to any of the many other new communication or
entertainment technologies so ubiquitous in our society, or how
computers are changing the way we think.[5] How do all these gadgets
affect our lives?
Lisa Ryan, Director of the
Cornell College of Agriculture and Life Sciences
Counseling and Advising office, recently told the
Christian Faculty/Staff Forum that her office has
seen a steady rise in students with personal and academic problems.
One of the key contributing factors is the isolating effect of these
technologies. Students get less and less "face time"-actual
physical presence-and they're suffering in profound
ways.
Which brings me back to Ken
Myers's editorial. He thinks the cell phone manners he is advocating
"could demonstrate the high value that Christians place on
embodiment, expressed in our doctrines of Creation, Incarnation, and
Resurrection." He continues,
What could cell phones
possibly have to do with the Incarnation? Both involve the
significance of physical, embodied presence before others. The
presence of another person before us is a kind of moral claim, asking
for the recognition appropriate to a fellow human being. Likewise,
when we make ourselves present to others, we are showing respect. Thus
when we visit someone in the hospital or in prison (a situation Jesus
alludes to in Matthew 25) instead of just phoning or sending flowers,
we demonstrate by our presence a higher level of regard for their
well-being.[6]
This year's annual Upstate New
York Faculty Conference, co-sponsored by Chesterton House and
InterVarsity Christian Fellowship, brings
Dr. David Lyon, a sociologist from Queen's University in
Kingston, Ontario to guide us these matters. The conference is titled
"
Speeding and Shrinking: Living Biblically in
Technology-Saturated Times." Full information is at the
Chesterton House web site. We hope you can join
us for a biblical exploration of matters like mobility, technology and
relating, along with tentative socio-theologies of motor cars,
computers, digital cameras, microwaves and, yes, cell
phones.
- Christian Anible
[1] Ken Myers, "Dehumanizing Tendencies
Should Be Put on Hold," Dallas Morning News, April 1,
2000.
[2] Linda Goodman, "How Not to Ring in
Thanksgiving Break, The Cornell Daily Sun, November 21,
2000.
[3] Missy Kurzwell, "Ya Wanna Lie? Use
the Phone," The Cornell Daily Sun, February 26,
2004.
[4] Elisa Batista, "Phone Becomes Alibi
for Liars," Wired, May 14, 2004.
[6] Myers, op. cit.
COMING
EVENTS
Weekly when
Cornell is in session:
Fridays,
1:00-5:00pm -- Resource Room Open Hours
Friday, April
8, 7:30pm
"Engaging a Pluralistic
Culture with a Faithful Gospel"
Ryan Messmore, Trinity Forum
Academy
Cornell Christian
Fellowship
Auditorium D, Goldwin Smith
Hall
Saturday,
April 9, 9:30am-4:00pm
"Speeding &
Shrinking: Living Biblically in Technology-Saturated
Times"
Dr. David Lyon, Sociologist,
Queen's University
Upstate NY InterVarsity Faculty
Conference
One World Room, Anabel Taylor
Hall
Register:
http://www.chestertonhouse.org
Saturday,
April 16, 7:00pm
"Science: Atheistic or
Christian?"
Dr. Ian
Hutchinson, Physicist, MIT
Graduate
Christian Fellowship
Big Red
Barn
Friday, April
22, 7:30pm
Movie Night: "Big
Fish"
Cornell Christian
Fellowship
Auditorium D,
Goldwin Smith Hall
All Chesterton
House events are open to the public.
ALSO OF
INTEREST
Saturday,
April 16th, 1:00pm
"GK
Chesterton On Stage"
Dale Ahlquist &
Chuck Chalberg
135 Basil Hall,
St. John Fisher College, Rochester
Rochester, NY
Chesterton Society
Sunday-Wednesday, May 8-11
"Creating
Conversations"
Featuring Steven
Garber and others
3rd Annual Summer Institute on
Faith & the University
Christian Study
Center, Gainesville, FL
http://summerinstitute.christianstudycenter.org
EASTER
Emerging
technologies, of course, do have their benefits. One such
benefit is the opportunity to subscribe to daily devotionals by email,
such as Chesterton House advisory board member D.A. Carson's
For
the Love of God. Carson's reflections walk through the Bible
over the course of a year, always emphasizing the unity of Scripture
and the history of redemption. I have subscribed for one full
year and recommend it highly. For more information, or to
subscribe, see
http://www.christwaymedia.com. Occasionally
Carson breaks out in song, as with these reflections on the
resurrection:
They came alone: some women
who remembered him,
Bowed down with spices to anoint his corpse.
Through darkened streets, they
wept their way to honor him--
The one whose death had shattered
all their hopes.
"Why do you look for life among the sepulchers?
He is not here. He's risen,
as he said.
Remember how he told you while in
Galilee:
The Son of Man will die--and rise
up from the dead."
The two walked home, a study in defeat and loss,
Explaining to a stranger why the
gloom--
How Jesus seemed to be the King
before his cross,
How all their hopes lay buried in
his tomb.
"How slow you are to see
Christ's glorious pilgrimage
Ran through the cross"--and
then he broke the bread.
Their eyes were opened, and they
grasped the Scripture's truth:
The man who taught them had
arisen from the dead.
He was a skeptic: not for him that easy faith
That swaps the truth for sentimental sigh.
Unless he saw the nail marks in his hands himself,
And touched his side, he'd not
believe the lie.
Then Jesus came, although the
doors were shut and locked.
"Repent of doubt, and reach into my side;
Trace out the wounds that nails
left in my broken hands.
And understand that I who speaks
to you once died."
Long years have passed, and still we face the fear of death,
Which steals our loved ones, leaving us undone,
And still confronts us, beckoning with icy breath,
The final terror when life's
course is run.
But this I know: the Savior
passed this way before,
His body clothed in immortality.
The sting's been drawn: the
power of sin has been destroyed.
We sing: Death has been
swallowed up in victory.
-D.A. Carson
The first two verses of this poem
are a meditation on part of Luke 24:1 - 8, 13 - 25. The last two
verses draw on other resurrection accounts (John 20:24 - 29; Heb. 2:14
- 15; 1 Cor. 15:50 - 58). It may be sung to the Londonderry Air
("Danny Boy").
MATCHING GIFT
UPDATE
In December we
announced that two Cornell faculty families have pledged a generous
matching challenge grant designed to encourage a broad base of friends
and alumni to give generously toward the ministry's vision of
assisting students integrating faith with learning. We are
seeking to raise $200,000 by January 2006 in order trigger the full
$100,000 matching grant. We have currently raised just over
$25,000 from individuals toward this goal. We invite you to prayerfully join us in
this fundraising campaign. Future plans
for Chesterton House begin with hiring a full-time director and
increasing our level of programming, including offering classes for
credit, hosting multiple reading groups, mentoring, and developing new
on-line resources. More information, including guidelines
for the matching gift campaign, can be found at
http://www.chestertonhouse.org/funding.
"For the wise men of old the cardinal problem
had been how to conform the soul to reality, and the solution had been
knowledge, self-discipline, and virtue. For magic and applied science
alike the problem is how to subdue reality to the wishes of men: the
solution is a technique."
-CS Lewis